Ricciarelli Almond Paste Cookie Recipe | Lemons + Anchovies (2024)

I can’t remember the last time, if ever, I strolled down Half Moon Bay’s Main Street. In recent years I’ve popped into the Ritz Carlton on the cliffs, have had the occasional lunch near the beach and visited one of the two large nurseries to pick up ceramic flower pots for my backyard but it had never occurred to me to check out the historic downtown area. After many years of just passing through on my way home from the coast, I finally spent a leisurely afternoon last week becoming acquainted with Main Street.

Because of the absence of the weekend crowd parking was easy. Several shops drew me in and I took note of a few restaurants that I might drag my husband to sometime. There were a couple of housewares stores–one in particular, Toque Blanche, grabbed my attention then held me hostage for the next half hour. Everywhere I turned I found something I “needed”, from essential cooking tools to Italian ceramics and even handmade rolling pins. When I discovered their alcove with a fine collection of cookbooks at the back of the store I vowed to return for some Christmas shopping but didn’t wait to snag two books for my own collection.

It was about tea time when I decided to make my way home. Conveniently, Moonside Bakery & Cafe was right next door. Despite the inviting array of freshly baked pies I knew that the Almond Horns would be accompanying my cup of tea as soon as I spotted them. The owner of the European-style bakery is a Certified Master Pastry Chef and most of the breads, pies and pastries are made on the premises.

The almond horns (aka almond crescents or mandelhörnchen in German) were an A+ in my book. With an almond paste base, the little cookies were slightly crisp outside and soft and chewy inside. Not overly sweet, I inhaled the chocolate-dipped treat in no time. Determined to recreate them for the holidays, I became obsessed with finding guidance on the web.

The almond horns didn’t happen because of a shortage of sliced almonds in my pantry so I considered making a cookies instead. The ingredients are very simple–even making your own almond paste like I do–you need mainly almonds, egg whites and powdered sugar. How fortuitous it was to find the very type of cookie I wanted to make as I leafed through one of the cookbooks I bought at Toque Blanche. Ricciarelli are Italian almond paste-based cookies that date back to 14th century Siena. They were regarded as a treat for the nobility because of the expensive ingredients, almonds and sugar, and were often served alongside dessert wine. Over time they became a Christmas tradition but these days they are a common offering in Italian sweet shops.

The tops should be more crackled according to web images of the same cookie and I understand now that it’s because I might have used a bit more flour to work with the very sticky dough. I know how to avoid this next time but this version is no slouch at all. I used my homemade almond paste and added more almond meal to my version but otherwise I stuck to the recipe. A bit crisp at the bottom and soft on top and inside, these ricciarelli were not sweet at all but were rich with almond flavor–exactly what I was after.

Next on the to-do list, Almond Horns…and a return to downtown Half Moon Bay.