Shortbread Recipe | Chelsea Sugar (2024)

Reviews

Average Rating
(162 reviews)

Thank you, I followed the recipe to the T the mixture was a little too wet so adjusted it by adding a little bit more flour until the I got it the way I would think it should be. If I had more time I would have just placed into the fridge for a couple of hours. The cooking time was fine for me 25 minutes was good. Thank you for the lively easy recipe once again.

Made this twice over last week. So easy and melt in the mouth delicious .
First time just used spoonful of mixture and flattened with fork.
Today rolled it out..
Have tried other recipes in the past and not been successful so this one is the only one I would use.
Now to have a piece with coffee.

Best recipe ever.

Great recipe! I added a bit more flour to achieve a less sticky consistency. I also allowed the dough to firm up in the fridge for a couple of hours so that the cookies could hold their shape.

I have just made some shortbread. Very easy to work with but very soft. Went by the recipe ingredients but spread close together on tray. Cooked for 16 mins as looked done, but think they may of needed another 5 mins or so. So not sure what I did wrong...a little disappointed

Comments about this being sticky rap in baking paper and I always put mine in the fridge till hard and this makes it easier to cut place on tray and then place in oven can leave in fridge till you are ready to bake

Just made shortbread cookies with this recipe. They turned out great. We used gingerbread cookie cutters with the kiddos. :)

Best shortbread I've ever made!

Good recipe but time in oven is way too long. Mine were ready in 10 mins.

you have made so many recipes but this is the best . Thank you .

The mix was too sticky and wouldn't become doughy. Recipe needs more of the dry ingredients.

Tried and true!

yuummy but bum bum bum bum. you??????????????

cool video guys. love it. everything. do you love it???

Delicious

Delish! cookies love making them with my toddler!xx

Amazing shortbread. Best recipe found. Thanks heaps.

This is the second time I have used this recipe its very easy to make and I cooled in fridge before working as it was very soft, lovely texture when cooked and very
moreish.

Yeah, the comments echoed my thoughts about the butter content being a bit too much.

Amazing recipe for sure, has turned out great every time. Only issue is that you have to add a lot of extra flour to the dough to make it less sticky to work with

I added an extra half-cup of flour because it was too sticky. Gently rolled it out 1cm thick and used small round cookie cutter. Baked for only 16-18 mins. Came out perfect. Unless your cookies are super thick and large, 25-30mins is way too long.

Great recipe! I was surprised by some of the negative reviews as I thought the biscuits were delicious and had a lovely texture. My daughter and I will be using the recipe to bake and give out as Xmas gifts this year.

Nice basic recipe. I changed it from when the dough has been made, put in fridge. Once cool the dough is easier to form into shapes eg roll into balls shapes or as per video. Did not add sugar crystals. Seems a bit much. Cheers

I have made this

s several times now and very happy. For more crunch and less melt use half icing and half castor sugar.

First time making shortbread.
Settled on this recipe after reading reviews
Was quite sticky when I was trying to make into a roll. Was sticking to my hands. Added flour on board and hands and that helped.
Like that there was a video to watch as easy to understand the steps and what it should look like.
Still in the oven, looks good
Taste test when cold.
My neighbor , 91, always gives me feed back which I find helpful

Delish, especially with the addition of the finely grated rind of 2 lemons!

although ive eaten shortbread before ive never made it , this recipe didnt have ingrediants by the fist full , was easy to follow and the shortbread was yum.

I love this recipe, it is light a d buttery, my only shirt bread buscuit recipe.

Get recipes love it

This was great best ever I recommend

Love making this recipe. Doesn't last long. Yummy

Quick, easy to follow and melts in mouth. I love this for a little gift too. Everyone loves shortbread. Certainly a reliable go to recipe. Used premium flour, no problem. Video helpful for easy way to slice up evenly. Thank you Chelsea.

Quick, easy to follow and melts in mouth. I love this for a little gift too. Everyone loves shortbread. Certainly a reliable go to recipe. Used premium flour, no problem. Video helpful for easy way to slice up evenly. Thank you Chelsea.

YUM!! It tastes better than store-bought shortbread!

Have tasted this receipe where my cousin made it was so yummy

mm so yummy i loved them

Fantastic shortbread, family love it. I sometimes ice them

I have used this recipe for years and it is a winner every time. So smooth and delicious. Thanks for sharing.

Everyone says it's great

Love it

good and deli

good and deli

good and deli

Dough was far to sticky and not workable - ended up having to put in the fridge over night. Wouldn't recommend

Can this recipe be made with gluten free flour? Or rice flour? Thanks

Easy to make and very tasty especially with added ginger. The amounts are incorrect though, it needs extra dry ingredients, its almost a cup short.

wonderful recipe

I have made this recipe twice, both times I needed a little extra flour so I could get a workable dough.not sure if I am doing something wrong here? Tastes lovely once made. Very popular with friends & family and friends

nice

Yummy

A nice recipe overall

Made so many, and ended up being sooooooo dry and weird tasting.

Wow this is so yummy ,My family loved it

Great easy recipe

Turn out really nice and kids loved it.

Worst recipe ever, much too sweet, baking time much too long. Not recommendable

I added 2 tsp coffee granules and 1 tsp cracked pepper to this recipe – amazing also!

I have never made shortbread so good. This recipe is the best not had a failure yet . Add macadamias yum. Anyone who can't do this recipe should just buy store bought.

I add a little real vanilla essence and refrigerated the dough for an hour or so and sprinkled with caster sugar 5 minutes before taking them out of the oven. Lovely recipe and very easy. Just make sure the dough is not too thick or thin. I also sometimes dip half the biscuit in melts chocolate. A great recipe

Very poor example of shortbread, tried this recipe twice and it has failed both times

i found it far too soft to roll out So i patted it so i could cut it into rounds with cutter i even had to add more flour. But melted in my mouth after cooking.

Delicious. Lovely texture. From reading some of the other reviews I wonder if humidity affects the amount of flour. Fore-warned is fore-armed; I kept some extra flour handy. Great recipe, thank you.

I have been making this recipe for many years.....it is the best biscuit recipe ever, according to the grandchildren!

I made these with gluten free flour, and it was beautiful! Light and crispy, then melts in your mouth. I had to guard them from the kids as they were for a friend. I rolled it out between two pieces of baking paper and cut them with Christmas themed Cookie cutters.

Very yummy and easy recipe to follow: From Francis, 10 years old

Im a 58 year old bloke who knocks out a heap of this every week, wifey loves it and it's almost as good as grans used to be.

This is my go to recipe it's the best ever recipe. I have made them as a gift pack and people love them.

I love this recipe, and was making beautiful shortbread, but the last two times, the shortbread has come out really hard and crunchy...,please help...what am I doing wrong......butter too hard, not mixed enough with the icing sugar..... not chilled...overworked dough...??
CHELSEA SUGAR: Hi there, sorry to hear that! Yes, it might be that the butter was too hard (perhaps not helped by the cooler winter months?), not mixed in with the icing sugar long enough, or that the dough was overworked. We hope your next batch turns out well!

Best shortbread recipe you will find.

Shared them with friends! They are great, thanks Chelsea!

Yummy

A easy to follow recipe. Turned out perfect. Will add to my favorites.

They were delicious! Though they did spread out a lot on the tray while baking, so watch out for that. I also put some icing on them and it was delightful.

This was just like getting them from the cafe, love this recipe!

This is an amazing recipe, everyone ate them straight away!

Yummy

Kids love these - nice and chewy!

I accidentally added the cornflour in with the sugar and the shortbread still come out yum.
Thanks for an awesome recipe

After being told shortbread was hard to make. This recipe made is so simple. It tastes amazing as well. Can't wait to make more. One thing is to use a deep bowl so the flour doesn't fly everywhere!!!

Everyone loves this

Best and easiest recipe ever. Made a double batch and used the beater through the whole process. no kneading by hand. came out perfect and spread quite a bit. decorate with some melted choclate. yuuuuuuum

It was delicious with a hot cup of tea.... but not so great if you weren't looking for something sweet.
I enjoyed the shortbread very much though!

This is the loveliest shortbread... short, rich without being greasy. Loved by all. Also good with citrus zest in the mixture.

Partners just made a quick batch of short bread But mistakenly used baking powder instead of icing sugar tastes ok before cooking bit bitter but hey I'm grateful for the effort she's put in

Friends and family said best shortbread ever. I completely agree.

Great recipe. I made mine into little stars and it made 56. I also rooled mine out and used a cookie cutter.

Fantastic recipe, although i cooked for 17mins instead. Also spread them out!! Cooking anothe batch now as they got gobbled so fast! :)

A very easy shortbread recipe. Need to be careful with the amount of flour: don't add all at once. Gradually add as you knead to ensure the dough is of the right consistency. Not too dry or wet. Get that right and these are yummy!

Great recipe, have added white pepper and chopped cashews for a difference.

Excellent receipe, a great one to whip up before friends arrive

I am a Scot and have tasted heaps of shortbread and biscuits etc. Your recipe takes a bit to beat.

Great recipe, used it several times, light and crisp. Added lemon zest for added flavour tang to counter sweetness.

THE BEST SHORTBREAD COOKIES EVER. GO CHELSEA!

I should have made this recipe. I made the Edmonds one because everyone said how good it was and it wouldn't hold together. Comparing the amount of dry ingredients, the Edmonds one has 2 cups of flour, 1 cup of icing sugar and 1 cup of corn flour which is a whole 1 1/4 cups more than this recipe has. I will certainly be making this one next time.

I think its great but the flour mesurments are very wrong. I ended up putting a lot more than it said to due to how sticky the dough was. Turned out yummy though :) Great with tea.

I'd never made biscuits before, but a few weeks ago I made Afghans (Chelsea recipe) and they've been a sensational hit. Today I made the Chelsea shortbread, first time ever, and 10 x the recipe, and bingo, instant success. Lots of mouths to feed at FFL in Whangarei, and everyone's loving the biscuits. Thanks Chelsea.

Yum

A few years ago I always failed at Shortbread, then I met someone that gave me a recipe and also talked me through how to make Shortbread properly. I am here today as I have misplaced that recipe, but I have used this one and applied the Shortbread making skills I learnt from my very good recipe. So, Shortbread is about feel, and it should be kneeded by hand until the dough all forms a solid all and no longer sticks to the wall of the bowl. The flour quantity varies, and my recipe had a range for the quantity. I applied that here, so following other reviewers complaints the dough was too soft, I put the entire 1.5cups of flour in. Then I left the flour and cornflour open next to my bowl and proceeded to kneed the dough. Once I established the consistency, I literally added just a small hand grab of each type of flour, and got that silky smooth ball of dough I was looking for. They have just come out of the over and look absolutely perfect. I have only given 4 stars as I feel your recipe should read 1.5 to 1.75 cups of flour as required. Then it would be perfect.

The shortbread biscuits were great!!! I loved them. I added a little more flour to the recipe as they were a little sticky but really fantastic!!!

Super easy to make and delicious!

This recipe is great. I doubled the mixture and it was still perfect. If the dough was too soft I add a little more flour, quarter cup at a time until it isn't sticky. Still come out the way shortbread should. Love it.

This recipe is amazing it works every time, I was wondering if the flour could be swapped for gluten free flour.

Perfect recipe. Is now my favourite shortbread recipe, and one I will stick to in years to come. Turns out beautifully, taste just like my Grandma used to make! :)

The shortbread is lovely . I took the advise of others and left it in the fridge to cut before baking. I found it was too wet to roll out.

It is THE best recipe for shortbread. Melt in your mouth, buttery and sweet!

I had to try the recipe after reading all the great comments! Its a fantastic recipe just finished my 2x batches, It melts in the mouth!!!

So perfect so good so yummy

I don't think the flour amounts are correct. I had to put a lot more corn flour and plain flour to be able to roll it with 250g margerine. It worked out just fine.

Perfect shortbread

I used soft brown sugar as I ran out of icing sugar. These are perfection!

It is AMAZINGLY EASY and delicious.

I love it

So good

Great recipe...so yummy..
It would stay long in my cookies jar.

Hi Chelsea. I'm quite new to baking. Just got into it after coming across Rosanna Pansino on youtube. As a semi-beginner, this is really easy for me to do!! thank you so much!! my favourite cookie recipe (that doesnt use confusing american measurements lol)

My husband who was a Swiss chef says this recipe is “ the best”. I add almond essence to the mix, as that is his favourite flavour. My son’s love them too, and often go home with a tin full. Friend’s always aske me for the recipe after sampling. I have to say they are my fav too.

best shortbread recipe

SO AWESOME AND SO EASY!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!
GREAT COOKIE TO BE ICED

love it

I had a massive failure with shortbread about 40 yrs ago but finally decided to give it another go. It was an unqualified success!!! I tried to use my beater but everything just clogged up so it was back to the wooden spoon.
The first batch is out (and taste tested) and the second batch due out in a few minutes. Many thanks for the great recipe.

We love this recipe

this recipe was great, simple and Yummy!

cool

cool

This recipe makes beautiful shortbread! I found that it works best by shaping the dough into a log shape on a granite board to keep it cool and then slice with a knife into half an inch slices to keep the shape uniform.

We love these biscuits. Ultimately melt in your mouth

Perfect for my bake sale I did for the SPCA.

It looks tastes and smells amazing try it you have to it is literally to die for amazing would rate it a 10 out of 10

Never made shortbread before, and was hoping to replicate the soft, creamy style of other peoples I'd tasted. Being December it was warm in the kitchen, so the dough was quite soft by the time I'd cut the biscuits out. They spread in the oven a little, so next time I will put in the fridge to chill before baking, or cut the biscuits smaller. This is why I gave it four stars. Otherwise they tasted delicious and I dipped some in chocolate. I used Lewis Road Creamery Lightly Salted Butter and added a little vanilla paste.

Best shortbread recipe ever- super light and crisp. I like to split the recipe into two logs, then roll one in coffee sugar crystals and the other in mini chocolate chips. I chill the logs before slicing and baking to make it easier. Perfect every time. Beautifully shaped and textured shortbread.

First lot were very neat and tidy and perfect.
Second lot had a few join up, the oven was hotter and the room was super warm but still they are beautiful.

taste really good perfect every time.

Best recipe. Biscuits won't last long in our house!! Thank you! !

Bad recipe. Dough is way too soft to work with, all the cookies loose their shape in the oven.

Pretty good. I added orange zest when I made this and dipped one end of each finger into melted chocolate.

I have been using this shortbread recipe through 6 grandchildren and 2 great grandchildren an this their favourite bikkie of all time, I am sure everyone who bakes these will also enjoy these biscuits.

Verry good for me.

This recipe is the best shortbread I have ever tasted!!!

I absolutely love it and my kids loved it also can't wait to have more!!! Thanks!!!

So sad! the whole tray of cookies melted together ad made a puddle of buttery mess.
CHELSEA: Hi there, sorry to hear this recipe didn't work out for you. Our key tips to ensure shortbread biscuit success are to make sure you only soften (not melt) the butter, bake the cookies in the centre of the oven and ensure the oven temperature isn't too hot.

Didn't work out for me. Given proportions resulted in a very soft dough which should have set the alarm bells. I formed it into a roll and chilled in the freezer for a while and was able to work with it to slice rounds. In the oven the butter melted, the biscuits all melded into one another - complete fail. So I compared other shortbread recipes. Edmonds Cookbook for instance calls for 250 g of butter and four cups of dry ingredients. This recipe calls for the same amount of butter and 2 3/4 cups of the same dry ingredients. I think this recipe is flawed and I'm disappointed I trusted it.
CHELSEA: Hi there, sorry to hear you've had a bad experience with this recipe. We recently tested this recipe when we made the video for it and found it to be one of the best shortbread recipes we've tried! It has similar ratios of ingredients to other shortbread recipes found online. Our top shortbread-making tips are to make sure the butter is just softened (not melted), the oven isn't too hot and the cookies are baked in the middle of the oven.

I'm assuming so, but can the uncooked dough be frozen?
CHELSEA: Yes it can, enjoy :-)

Yum Yum Yum- best shortbread ever

This is a fabulous receipe. It is my go to one for shortbread. I knead it a bit after mixing and before rolling in to a log shape and then refrigerating. When it is cold, slice it, thick or thin, whatever takes your fancy. Great mixture for rolling out and cutting into shapes for Christmas baking etc.
Everyone loves it and sometimes I add cocoa to make it chocolate shortbread.

Great shortbread recipe!

Could I use riceflour instead of cornflour?
CHELSEA: Hi there, yes you could use rice flour in place of the cornflour. The resulting shortbread may be a little crunchier.

The easiest most delicious shortbread ever. I have never had a failure with this recipe, although I always have to add a little more flour and cornflour.

I have been meaning to make shortbread bikkies for ages -
finally tried at half past midnight tonight & am presently
tasting the end product.. which is yummy.
and so quick to make.

This is the most perfect shortbread recipe. My child took this to camp and was a huge hit with all the children!!

I would recommend this to everyone and every occasion.

Lovely shortbread recipe, very buttery and just the right crunch factor!

Really easy and turns out great.

Lovely shortbread recipe.

love this shortbread recipe, so easy and quick to make and easy to eat.

Shortbread is amazing! I love eating it and literally can't stop! Awesome recipe!

Made these on the weekend so easy to make added cranberries to the mix and they were delish!

Amazing I LOVED IT yummy as well ;)

It was very delicious. My grandchildren loved making it with me! Full of amazing buttery goodness. 5/5!

Great and delicious

this is awesome totally gonna try it sure it will be great

Made several different shortbread recipes, this the best excellent blend sweetness butteriness crunch. Baked for 20 min at 150c very little color but perfect time.

It helps if you don't put brandy instead of vanilla essence.... still nice though

Delicious and buttery

Load More
Shortbread Recipe | Chelsea Sugar (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6043

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.